🧾 LLC vs S-Corp vs Sole Prop: What Actually Makes Sense For You?

Your business structure shouldn't require a law degree to figure out.

Choosing the right legal structure for your business feels like trying to pick the "right" tax code while blindfolded.

So here's the truth, without the jargon or fluff. This guide isn’t written for lawyers—it’s written for the freelancer, the solo tech, the lash artist, the side hustler who just wants to make sure they don’t get wrecked come tax season.

Let’s break it down.

🧍‍♂️ Sole Proprietorship

The default setup. You don’t even have to file anything.

Pros:

• Free and fast to start

• Easiest to manage

• Perfect for testing an idea before going all-in

Cons:

• No legal separation = your personal assets are on the line

• You pay self-employment tax on 100% of profit

• Doesn’t look very professional to banks, vendors, or partners

Best For: Side hustlers just getting started and taking low financial risk.

🧱 LLC (Limited Liability Company)

The “I’m serious now” structure.

Pros:

• Separates personal + business assets (this protects you if things go sideways)

• Flexible for solo owners or partners

• Easier tax filing than a corporation

• You can still file taxes as a Sole Prop or elect S-Corp status later

Cons:

• Costs ~$50–$300 to form depending on your state

• You’ll need to keep books, file annual reports, and possibly pay franchise taxes

• You still pay self-employment tax unless you elect S-Corp

Best For: Most service businesses, freelancers, and anyone ready to grow beyond “just a side hustle.”

✅ Pro Tip: File as an LLC now, and when you’re making ~$40K–$50K+ in profit annually, switch to S-Corp tax status for savings.

🏢 S-Corporation (Tax Status, Not a Legal Entity)

The "save-on-taxes" move for profitable businesses.

Pros:

• You don’t pay self-employment tax on your full profit

• You pay yourself a reasonable salary (W-2) and take the rest as distributions (which are taxed less)

• Big tax savings once your business income grows

Cons:

• More paperwork: payroll, quarterly taxes, bookkeeping

• You have to pay yourself a reasonable salary (not optional)

• Higher setup/maintenance costs (CPA highly recommended)

Best For: Businesses consistently profiting $40K+ per year that want to minimize taxes the legal way.

🔁 Real-Life Scenarios

You Are...	Start With...	Switch to...
Brand new freelancer	Sole Prop	LLC when you start earning
Running a home service biz	LLC	S-Corp when profit > $40K
Building a product company	LLC	S-Corp for tax planning
Selling digital stuff online	LLC	Maybe stay as LLC unless scale explodes

⚠️ Pro Warning:

S-Corp is not a flex if you’re broke. If you’re not netting real profit, the maintenance and payroll costs can cancel out the tax savings.

🧠 Final Thought:

You don’t need to get it perfect—you just need to protect yourself and plan ahead.

• If you’re testing an idea → Sole Prop is fine.

• If you’re earning and investing → LLC is your move.

• If you’re profiting consistently → Time to call your CPA and ask about S-Corp status.

Coming soon: The Entity Builder Checklist – everything you need to set up your business legally (without the overwhelm).

Affiliate links may support this blog. Appreciate you using them if you find this helpful.